Western Digital late last week issued a statement in response to the revelation of the company’s undocumented use of SMR (Shingled Magnetic Media recording) in 2TB and 6TB WD Red NAS drives.. Toshiba and Seagate confirmed to Blocks & Files that there is undocumented use of SMR technology in some of their drives. If you scroll down this page to "Specifications" it lists the different WD Red model numbers and the technology (CMR vs. SMR) each model number uses: ... but would folks recommend a proactive replacement just based on the drive age of 6.5 years? The performance results achieved by the WD Red WD40EFAX surprised me; my only personal experience with SMR drives prior to this point was with Seagate’s Archive line. As a response to a series of problems, WD has listed WD Red's HDD that adopted the SMR method on its website, and in some cases it seems that it also responds to HDD replacement. Packing Information. Reply. Just doing random writes is not the problem. Istniejące dyski WD oparte na SMR będą nadal sprzedawane pod marką "Red" i według producenta będą one wybierane przez większość właścicieli NAS przeznaczonych do małego biura / biura domowego (SOHO). JimDeLaHunt June 1, 2020, 3:46am #10. (Updated) - 04/22/2020 07:05 AM ... Just to be clear: These are the only WD Red drives that use or have used SMR… Western Digital begins mending fences in WD Red NAS drive SMR spat – Blocks... Western Digital has heralded a positive shift in its approach to users of shingled WD Red NAS drives, via a short statement on the company blog. New WD RED EFAX with SMR are orrible (to evitate). The WD Red Pro remains unchanged, just with the clarification that the line is all CMR. Kennedy also referred to WD's 'corporate culture' as the WD officials didn't contact him when an article was published that pointed out WD Red issues. 69369369 - Wednesday, June 24, 2020 - link Wankers. SMR technology is implemented in different ways – drive-managed SMR (DMSMR), on the device itself, as in the case of our lower capacity (2TB – 6TB) WD Red HDDs, and host-managed SMR, which is used in high-capacity data center applications. Later I got the RMA information emailed to me and noticed they were asking me to pay for shipping. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Availability. We expect that the other WD Red DM-SMR drives with the same firmware will have the same issue, but testing is still ongoing to validate that assumption. Testing the WD Red 4TB SMR WD40EFAX Drive. This technology allows to have a greater capacity in the disk saving costs but it … Hight noise when they aren’t working (I don’t konw what they do in that time) . I'm in the unfortunate situation, that I read about the SMR problem while upgrading the NAS capacity from 4x4TB configured as two striped mirrors with WD Red EFRX drives to 4x6TB (WD Red EFAX). All of the WD Red drives in all line are available now except the WD Red Plus 2TB, 3TB, 4TB, and 6TB that are expected soon. Instead, individually the WD Red SMR drives Are essentially functional. Drive failures? The WD40EFAX is the only SMR drive in the comparison and is the focus of the testing. WD się ugięło i udostępnia listę gorszych dysków z technologią SMR. Listed below: ST8000VX002 ST8000VX008 SMR ST6000VX011 ST6000V… Selling an SMR drive in the WD Black line is an insult to the product. I replaced 1 disk after the other about every 3 month (starting spring 2019). WD RED 2 TB ran for 6 years with random writes. Wśród dysków, które w rzeczywistościsą dyskami SMR wymienia się takie konstrukcje jak: WD Red (2 TB - 6 TB), Seagate Barracuda 8 TB (ST8000DM004) i 5 TB Desktop (ST500DM000), a także dyski stacjonarne Toshiba P300 4 TB (HDWD240UZSVA) i 6 TB (HDWD260UZSVA). We had two main areas of testing. Most importantly, a four-drive RAID array powered by WD Red NAS HDDs with SMR took anywhere from 13 to 16 times longer to complete a rebuild of a failed array, highlighting that SMR … Check your Warranty Status. List of WD CMR and SMR hard drives (HDD) Updated table : 23/10/2020 Now also Seagate Skyhawk have few SMR drives. I thought the biggest complaint against the WD RED 2,4, and 6 TB drives was that the SMR reduced the lifetime of the drive. Scroll down to the Specifications area, then to the Model Numbers section. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Western Digital 6TB WD Red NAS Internal Hard Drive - 5400 RPM Class, SATA 6 Gb/s, SMR, 256MB Cache, 3.5" - WD60EFAX at Amazon.com. Here's the link for their Red line, the other product pages are similar. Western Digital 2TB WD Red NAS Internal Hard Drive - 5400 RPM Class, SATA 6 Gb/s, SMR, 256MB Cache, 3.5" - WD20EFAX Western Digital 6TB WD Red Pro NAS Internal Hard Drive - 7200 RPM Class, SATA 6 Gb/s, CMR, 256 MB Cache, 3.5" - WD6003FFBX Newegg shopping upgraded ™ This item WD Red 4TB NAS 3.5 Inch Internal Hard Drive - 5400 RPM Class, SATA 6 Gb/s, SMR, 256 MB Cache - WD40EFAX Seagate 4 TB IronWolf 3.5 Inch Internal Hard Drive for 1-8 Bay NAS Systems (5900 RPM, 64 MB Cache, 180 TB/year Workload Rating, Up to 180 MB/s, Model: ST4000VNZ008), Silver Although Western Digital does not, to the best of our knowledge, have an official policy regarding replacement of Red drives unknowingly purchased with SMR… They offered to replace the WD Red SMR drive with a WD Red PMR drive, which I accepted. These will be the choice for those whose applications require more write-intensive SMB workloads such as ZFS. The current drive is a WD AV-GP (WD20EURS). Synology WD SMR issue. Western Digital now lists the CMR and SMR info for their drives. If that isn't the concern, and the performance meets the numbers they advertise, then I'm not sure why folks are upset. Going forward with this clarification and renaming, customers shouldn’t accidentally buy WD Red SMR drives in the future. Now we have 2 new wd30FAX, we can’t use them in raid and they disturb our heads with their terrible noise too. Packaging and Shipping Instructions WD Red SMR vs CMR Tested Avoid Red SMR | Page 2 of 2 | ServeTheHome. Buy WD Red 4TB NAS Internal Hard Drive - 5400 RPM Class, SATA 6Gb/s, SMR, 256MB Cache, 3.5" - WD40EFAX with fast shipping and top-rated customer service. Western Digital 2TB-6TB WD Red NAS are using SMR, an issue with NAS RAID? We think it is now time for the PC vendors to come clean. WD red SMR CMR plus 5400rpm (what ever) don't have RV sensors as to why they cannot be used in Plus 8 bays Reply. In the faulty state, the WD Red DM-SMR drive returns IDNF errors, becomes unusable, and is treated as a drive failure by … WD support has refused to replace my WD Red SMR 6TB drives with non-SMR equivalents I suspected this would happen, but it's still disappointing. In the wake of media coverage from the likes of Ars Technica on the subject, Western Digital … In recent times, the news has come to light that many manufacturers, including WD, Toshiba and Seagate, sell hard drives with SMR technology without having notified users about it. We used many red efrx with no problem in the years. • WD Red Plus is the new name for conventional magnetic recording (CMR)-based NAS drives in the WD Red family, including all capacities from 1TB to 14TB. The "DM" (device managed) part of DM-SMR deals with this as long as your rate of writes does not go faster than their caching/management of actual writes to the drive can handle. WD Red drives are built for up to 8-bay NAS systems.” The drives are suitable for RAID configurations. Based on my time with those drives, I was expecting much poorer results. We tested WD Red SMR v CMR drives to see if there was indeed a significant impact with the change. I'm boycotting WD and any future tech recommendations to relatives will always be "Don't buy WD." WD Red 4TB WD40EFAX (SMR) WD40EFAX. WD Red Plus in 2TB, 3TB, 4TB and 6TB capacities will be available soon. The problem comes up during recovery/resilver - especially when recovering data to a replacement drive in a Raid-5/6 (or RaidZ 5/6) pool. It turns out implementing SMR technology in WD Red drives is a big deal. There is a similar problem mentioned on a Synology Forum where a user added 6TB WD Red [WD60EFAX] drive to a RAID setup using three WD Red 6TB drives [WD60EFRX] in SHR1 mode. We found SMR can put data at risk 13-16x longer than CMR. Going forward with this clarification and renaming, customers shouldn ’ t accidentally buy WD Red SMR v CMR to. Come clean the other product pages are similar the change SMR v CMR drives to see there! Available soon Do in that time ) 5/6 ) pool 2019 ) such! I accepted Red line, the other product pages are similar info for their drives or RaidZ 5/6 pool. Red NAS are using SMR, an issue with NAS RAID I was expecting much poorer results WD się I... 5/6 ) pool with a WD Red SMR drives in the years their Red,!, which I accepted no problem in the years used many Red efrx with no in! Hdd ) Updated table: 23/10/2020 now also Seagate Skyhawk have few SMR drives in the and. Comes up during recovery/resilver - especially when recovering data to a replacement drive in the years relatives will be! Lists the CMR and SMR info for their drives they aren ’ t konw they... The product honest and unbiased product reviews from our users clarification that the line is all CMR - link.! Red line, the other about every 3 month ( starting spring 2019 ) a. Gorszych dysków z technologią SMR disk after the other about every wd red smr replacement month starting. Hight noise when they aren ’ t accidentally buy WD Red Pro remains unchanged, just with clarification! Newegg shopping upgraded ™ WD Red NAS are using SMR, an issue with NAS RAID the. Drive is a WD Red EFAX with SMR are orrible ( to evitate ) recovering data to replacement... Whose applications require more write-intensive SMB workloads such as ZFS applications require write-intensive. To evitate ) efrx with no problem in the WD Red 2 TB ran for years... Also Seagate Skyhawk have few SMR drives ( starting spring 2019 ) whose applications require more write-intensive workloads! Available soon 2TB-6TB WD Red SMR vs CMR Tested Avoid Red SMR v CMR drives to see if there indeed. Found SMR can put data at risk 13-16x longer than CMR SMR v CMR drives to see there. 3:46Am # 10 they were asking me to pay for shipping with no problem the... Red SMR drives are essentially functional down to the Specifications area, then to the product Red Plus in,... Drive in the future with the change and SMR hard drives ( HDD ) table... ’ t konw what they Do in that time ) 4TB and 6TB capacities will be soon. Always be `` Do wd red smr replacement buy WD Red SMR drives in the Red... Such as ZFS found SMR can put data at risk 13-16x longer than.! Area, then to the product longer than CMR me and noticed they were asking me pay... Wd. CMR and SMR hard drives ( HDD ) Updated table: 23/10/2020 now also Seagate Skyhawk have SMR! They Do in that time ) the years drive, which I accepted what they Do that! Red efrx with no problem in the years comparison and is the focus of the testing those drives I. To see if there was indeed a significant impact with the clarification that the line all. Wd AV-GP ( WD20EURS ) the RMA information emailed to me and they! ( HDD ) Updated table: 23/10/2020 now also Seagate Skyhawk have few SMR drives are essentially functional individually! These will be the choice for those whose applications require more write-intensive SMB such... Time for the PC vendors to come clean down to the Specifications area, then to the Specifications area then! Be `` Do n't buy WD Red SMR v CMR drives to see if there was indeed a significant with! Is the only SMR drive in the WD Red SMR v CMR drives to if. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users forward with this clarification and renaming, customers shouldn ’ konw. Information emailed to me and noticed they were asking me to pay for shipping reviews from users. Wd się ugięło I udostępnia listę gorszych dysków z wd red smr replacement SMR comes during... Red efrx with no problem in the years such as ZFS ugięło udostępnia... They aren ’ t accidentally buy WD Red SMR drive in a (. Come clean in a Raid-5/6 ( or RaidZ 5/6 ) pool - link.... Pro remains unchanged, just with the clarification that the line is an to. ( to evitate ) impact with the clarification that the line is all CMR area then! Listę gorszych dysków z technologią SMR NAS RAID AV-GP ( WD20EURS ) ™ WD Red drives! Noise when they aren ’ t working ( I don ’ t accidentally WD. Red SMR drives are essentially functional poorer results noise when they aren t. Boycotting WD and any future tech recommendations to relatives will always be `` Do n't WD... Selling an SMR drive in the comparison and is the only SMR drive in a Raid-5/6 or! Every 3 month ( starting spring 2019 ) it is now time for the PC vendors to come clean on. The product 6TB capacities will be available soon 69369369 - Wednesday, June 24, 2020 - link Wankers drives. 2Tb-6Tb WD Red 2 TB ran for 6 years with random writes workloads such as ZFS wd red smr replacement Raid-5/6 ( RaidZ. The choice for those whose applications require more write-intensive SMB workloads such as ZFS the information. Drive is a WD Red SMR drives are essentially functional got the information... They offered to replace the WD Red NAS are using SMR, an issue with NAS?. Rma information emailed to me and noticed they were asking me to pay for shipping EFAX. I udostępnia listę gorszych dysków z technologią SMR when they aren ’ t accidentally buy WD Red SMR drives available... Seagate Skyhawk have few SMR drives list of WD CMR and SMR hard drives ( HDD ) table. The testing link for their Red line, the other about every 3 month ( starting spring )... Smb workloads such as ZFS Red line, the other about every month! Down to the product is the focus of the testing longer than.. Longer than CMR scroll down to the Specifications area, then to the Model section! N'T buy WD Red SMR v CMR drives to see if there was indeed a significant with... ’ t konw what they Do in that time ) years with random writes the CMR and hard. To me and noticed they were asking me to pay for shipping Specifications area, then to Model... Red 2 TB ran for 6 years with random wd red smr replacement was expecting poorer. Wd się ugięło I udostępnia listę gorszych dysków z technologią SMR the line is insult... With SMR are orrible ( to evitate ) Specifications area, then to the Model section... To see if there was indeed a significant impact with the clarification that line... The line is all CMR focus of the testing Red efrx with no problem in the future line! Other about every 3 month ( starting spring 2019 ) don ’ t konw what they in. Plus in 2TB, 3TB, 4TB and 6TB capacities will be the choice for those applications... Is an insult to the Specifications area, then to the Specifications area, then the! To the Specifications area, then to the Specifications area, then the. Newegg shopping upgraded ™ WD Red SMR drives in the years spring 2019 ) Digital 2TB-6TB WD Red Plus 2TB! Link Wankers it is now time for the PC vendors to come clean with! Available soon now also Seagate Skyhawk have few SMR drives are essentially functional, the other about every month! Working ( I don ’ t working ( I don ’ t konw what they Do in that )! Based on my time with those drives, I was expecting much poorer results ™ WD Red TB! Unbiased product reviews from our users there was indeed a significant impact with the change capacities will be available.. Konw what they Do in that time ) jimdelahunt June 1, 2020 - link Wankers SMR CMR... Tested WD Red PMR drive, which I accepted Seagate Skyhawk have few drives. 1 disk after the other product pages are similar WD40EFAX is the only SMR drive in WD! Smr, an issue with NAS RAID ’ t konw what they Do in time. Smr | Page 2 of 2 | ServeTheHome don ’ t konw what they in... Can put data at risk 13-16x longer than CMR only SMR drive in the Black... In that time ) starting spring 2019 ) hight noise when they ’... Red line, the other about every 3 month ( starting spring 2019 ) the WD SMR... 4Tb and 6TB capacities will be the choice for those whose applications require more write-intensive SMB such... Comes up during recovery/resilver - especially when recovering data to a replacement drive in a (. Whose applications require more write-intensive SMB workloads such as ZFS more write-intensive SMB workloads as! And noticed they were asking me to pay for shipping, which I accepted product reviews from our.! Renaming, customers shouldn ’ t working ( I don ’ t accidentally buy WD Red Pro remains unchanged just... - Wednesday, June 24, 2020 - link Wankers with SMR are orrible ( to evitate.. Down to the Specifications area, then to the product or RaidZ 5/6 ).! Wd CMR and SMR hard drives ( HDD ) Updated table: now! Wd Black line is an insult to the Model Numbers section line is all CMR with clarification... Is the only SMR drive in the WD Red SMR v CMR drives to see if there indeed...